Anyone who has ever taken care of a 4-year-old knows that they are overly active, adventurous…and hard to keep still, especially while on the wheels! Sadly, not all standard car seats can offer the level of security needed to keep your high-energy little ones safe on the road.
Safest Car Seats for 4-Year-Old Kids
We understand how much of a priority your child’s wellbeing and comfort should be, and how much of a challenge car journeys can pose, so we’ve taken the stress and worry out of car seat shopping to identify a selection of the safest, most comfortable car seats your 4-year-old should have, rather than wading through a sea of the less suitable options they could have.
Our top picks for the 7 safest car seats for 4-year-olds cover a range of heights and weights to help you find your child’s perfect fit, but to make sure you can always shop with confidence and know what to look for, let’s first get into some general shopping tips for choosing a safe car seat.
How to Pick the Right Car Seat for Your 4-Year-Old (Buyer’s Guide)
While safety should always be the first thing on your mind, there are plenty of other factors you should consider when shopping for a car seat for your 4-year-old to ensure it’s exactly what they need and will offer you the best value for your money.
Size
Car seats come in different sizes, covering a range of lengths, heights, and widths. For example, a Toyota Corolla is smaller than a Toyota Avalon but bigger than a Kia Picanto. While ensuring the seat is high enough to fully protect your child’s back with no overhang may seem straightforward, you’ll need to make sure it doesn’t block your view in the mirror or compromise the safety of your driving.
What’s more, making sure the seat is long enough for your child to be supported and protected, yet it still fits on the seats in your vehicle without having to adjust them, is equally important to ensure all passengers are as safe and comfortable as possible throughout your journeys.
To get the right car seat, you’ll first have to measure the dimensions of your car seats and the height, seat width, and length your child needs, then buy a seat that is within those dimensions.
Type of Car Seat
Since you’re buying a car seat for a 4-year-old, you’ll definitely be going for a front-facing car seat. However, for maximum value for money, if you plan on expanding your family, consider investing in convertibles that can function as both rear and front-facing car seats.
Some car seats also offer a backless mode for when kids get older. This means the back support can be detached from the base, which is usually more comfortable than standard vehicle seats. In backless mode, the vehicle’s seat will serve as a back support, giving extra comfort along with the peace of mind that comes with knowing your child can still be securely buckled in.
As we said earlier, convertibles double as both a rear-facing and front-facing car seat. Rear-facing car seats are ideal options for children below 24 months, but as they grow older, you’ll have to switch to front-facing car seats. If you also have kids under 4 that may also need a car seat, consider getting them a convertible for quality and versatility that lasts well into the future
Safety
Safety is one of the most important features to consider when buying a good child car seat. Some car seats come with inbuilt security features like side implants that boost the safety of the seat during use, but these can ramp up the price in some brands. Fortunately for you, our list has been specially curated with options that offer a level of safety you can rely on at affordable prices.
Ease of Installation
The installation of your child’s car seat is another important thing to consider. If you’re going to move the car seat in and out of your vehicle a lot, then you should focus on car seats that offer an easy installation system to reduce the inconvenience of moving the seat from car to car between uses.
Another thing to look out for is the buckling system of the seat. It should be comfortable, secure and easy to use. When thinking about securing the seat itself to your vehicle, it’s also important to ensure that the seat is compatible with the inbuilt seatbelts of every vehicle you’re planning to use it in.
Okay, we’ve covered the most important considerations, so let’s get on with the list!
Safest Car Seats: Our Top 7 Picks for 4-Year-Old Kids
1. Graco Extend2Fit Convertible Car Seat
The Graco Extend2Fit is just perfect for infants ranging from 4-50 lbs. and toddlers ranging from 22-65 lbs.
For most users, the main concerns when buying a child’s car seat are comfort and safety, and this seat promises only the best of both worlds. The Graco Extend2Fit features a 4-position extension panel that can be adjusted to provide additional legroom for the child as they grow, ensuring that they stay secure, and are as comfortable as possible even when rear-facing.
For safety, the Graco Extend2Fit features a Simply Safe Adjust Harness System that keeps your child secure throughout your rides. You can easily adjust the height of the harness and headrest to keep your child comfortable and secure as they get older, making for a versatile option that has the potential to be perfect for your child for years to come.
Another feature that makes this car seat an obvious choice for this list is its headrest, which has a 10-position range and adds to the adaptability of the seat to offer your child maximum comfort and safety to suit them as they get older.
Most parents gave this car seat the thumbs-up for its affordability and amazing features—especially when it comes to made-to-measure safety and comfort—but there are a few drawbacks it’s good to know about before you invest your hard-earned cash.
Cleaning the seat isn’t the easiest, as the cover is held on by hooks that some users report are tough to use. This is a real shame, especially if the seat is used as frequently and for as long as its other features allow.
While the safety system of this seat is undeniably top-notch, getting things secure on your own could pose a challenge. Some parents have mentioned how difficult it is to tighten the harness straps and get the LATCH and seat belt installation tight enough to hold the seat securely without assistance, and a few mentioned that they couldn’t get the seat to recline enough for the headrest to properly support their child’s head and neck without slumping.
That said, we’ve found that handling the harness straps, LATCH, and seat belt installation can affect new car seat users quite commonly, but they quickly get the hang of the system after the first or second use.
After some testing, we also found that perseverance and a crotchet hook will speed up removal of the seat cover for washing and reapplication once clean, so don’t let that put you off if you think the Graco Extend2Fit could be the pick for you.
Features
- Recommended Weight (rear-facing): 4-50 lbs.
- Recommended Weight (front-facing): 22-65 lbs.
- 6-Position Recline
- 10-Position Headrest
- 4-Position Extension Panel
- Simply Safe Adjust Harness System
Pros
- Easy to install.
- Provides ample legroom, with the option to extend for growing kids.
- Offers top-notch safety features.
- The seat is designed to be comfortable and sturdy.
Cons
- The cover can be difficult to remove and reapply before and after cleaning.
- Harness and seat belt installation may pose a challenge for users to do alone at first.
2. Britax Frontier ClickTight
The Britax Frontier ClickTight is an amazing offering when it comes to car seats for 4-year-olds, and a little discussion of its features explains why it’s an obvious choice for our list.
This booster seat offers one-click installation thanks to its ClickTight technology, and that means transferring the seat from car to car couldn’t be easier for busy parents with more than one vehicle.
It has a great weight range, and can support children from 25 to 120 pounds, making worrying about buying larger car seats as your kid grows older a thing of the past.
In terms of safety features, the Britax Frontier ClickTight features 2 layers of side-impact protection, an impact-absorbing base, a steel frame, and a v-shaped tether that reduces forward movement even in the event of sudden stops.
These safety features sound really great on paper, but in reality, they are even better. Some parents who purchased the seat have commented on how it saved their children during real-life road accidents, which goes a long way to prove just how much Britax have invested in making this seat safe and comfortable for your child, and how well it works in practice.
This car seat also features front-facing recline capabilities and a 9-position harness that should provide optimal comfort for your child even as they grow.
The cover of the Britax Frontier ClickTight is easy to clean, but unfortunately, is not machine washable. Hand washing the seat cover could be inconvenient for busy parents, so it’s worth thinking about whether this seat is worth the extra effort before buying.
Many users have reported difficulty in tightening the harness fitted on the Britax Frontier ClickTight during installation. Care must be taken to ensure the harness is properly fitted and doesn’t come loose while driving, but once tightened to the proper degree, you can rest assured that your child is completely safe and secure throughout use.
Features
- Harness Mode: Supports 25-90 pounds
- Booster Mode: Supports 40-120 pounds
- Layers of Protection: 2
- Quick–Adjust Harness: 9 positions
- Recline Positions: 2
Pros
- Easy to install.
- Boasts top-rated safety features.
- The cover is easy to remove for cleaning.
Cons
- Not machine washable.
- The harness can be difficult to tighten.
3. Graco Tranzitions 3-in-1 Harness Booster Seat
The Graco Tranzitions booster seat is a booster seat with all the right safety features to keep a growing child safe. The seat supports weights ranging from 22–100 lbs., which should be ample to suit your 4-year-old.
This seat comes with several amazing features that make it comfortable, sturdy, and easy to install. It also has a backless mode, making it a great pick for older kids who might still need some extra support. One thing’s for sure; this seat promises to be there to ensure your child’s safety and comfort for years to come.
The Graco Tranzitions offers reliable security, yet restraints that are so easy to fasten that your little one can buckle themselves in, promoting their independence and giving you maximum peace of mind. The kid-centric design of this seat doesn’t stop there, either; included in the seat are a storage container and cup holder that are perfect for storing fuel and entertainment on the go.
While this booster seat has many great features, it also has some flaws. Some parents reported that uninstalling the LATCH straps to move the seat from vehicle to vehicle posed a challenge due to the hook-style connectors attached to the seat, while others commented that the headrest wouldn’t support their child’s head when in the uppermost positions. Some users also experienced some issues with the LATCH straps coming loose, which leaves the seat unsecured.
If you choose to go for this seat, you should ensure that the LATCH straps are secured before driving off, but once done, you shouldn’t have any worries about the safety of the seat.
If you’re looking for a car seat for your 4-year-old that is effective, budget-friendly, and comfortable, then the Graco Tranzitions Booster Seat could be just what you need.
Features
- Harnessed car seat mode: 22-65 lbs.
- High-back mode: Supports 30-100 lbs.
- Backless mode: Supports 40-100 lbs.
- Integrated cup holder
- Machine washable
Pros
- Easy to install
- Boasts top-rated safety features
- Supports high back and backless support
Cons
- LATCH anchoring can come loose, leaving the seat unsecured if not checked prior to use.
4. Evenflo Big Kid AMP Booster Car Seat
The Evenflo Big Kid AMP supports high-back and booster seat use, and its impressive range of features and low price-tag easily makes it one of the best car seats for 4-year-olds on the market.
The Evenflo Big Kid AMP features 6 height settings to support your growing child as they develop, and the seat is perfect for long trips, thanks to being equipped with dual cup holders that are wide enough to store drinks, small toys, and snacks inside. It also has belt guides that help position the seat belt to be as efficient and comfortable as possible and make installing the seat and transferring it between vehicles a breeze.
The seat is also padded around the head and body, ensuring optimal comfort even on long haul trips.
Before purchasing this seat, ensure you take note of the weight and height recommendations. Your child should fall within both to ensure the seatbelt fits properly and is as secure and comfortable as possible, but as long as this is the case, we see no reason why this seat wouldn’t be a great pick for any family.
Features
- High-back mode: Supports 30-110 lbs.
- Backless mode: Supports 40-110 lbs.
- Dual cup holders
- 6 height adjustments
Pros
- The seat is made with comfortable padding.
- Includes dual cup holders.
- Machine-washable cover.
- Supports high back and backless use.
Cons
- More height adjustment options could be included — these are limited compared to some of our other picks.
5. Graco High-Back Turbobooster Car Seat
The Graco Turbobooster doubles as both a high-back and a backless booster and is one of the narrowest car seats you can find on the market today. You should be able to fit this seat in small spaces (including those measuring 16 inches or less) and move it about easily.
It features a multi-layer headrest and a full coverage back support, which ensures your child stays comfortable even during long road trips. Other features that are perfect for long-haul trips include dual cup holders and adjustable armrests.
The installation process of this car seat is made easy as pie by open-loop belt guides designed to help you correctly position your vehicle’s seat belt around the seat, and since it’s lightweight, you should be able to move the seat in and out of your vehicle with ease.
Some users have reported that when in high-back mode, the back of the seat sometimes comes loose or falls to a lower position in transit, while others have noted that the cup holders are a bit shallow for taller drinks. While the cup holder depth is minor, it’s worth noting there may be better alternatives out there for younger users or those who need extra support from their seats.
Despite this, most users love this seat, and its safety features, comfort, and ease of installation make it a great option if you’re looking for a car seat for your 4-year-old that is both affordable and has all the features listed above.
Features
- High-back mode: Supports 30-100 lbs.
- Backless mode: Supports 40-100 lbs.
- 6 height adjustments
Pros
- Dual hideaway cup holders
- Narrow enough to fit on small seats.
- Supports both high-back and backless use.
Cons
- Back may come loose while driving, so use with caution.
6. Evenflo Maestro Sport Harness Booster Car Seat
The Evenflo Maestro has many features that resemble those offered by other brands, but its unique blend of innovations for comfort, safety, and ease of use make it stand out as one of the best car seats for 4-year-olds on the market.
The Evenflo Maestro is a harnessed forward-facing car seat that offers high-back support and a backless mode for versatility that grows with your child. It also features dual cup holders, but these are streamlined to make the seat itself as compact as possible.
The foam used on the seat offers premium comfort users love, and the removable pillow is ideal for supporting sleepy heads on longer car trips.
This car seat is also aircraft approved in harness forward-facing mode, so is both uniquely versatile and great for families with a passion for travel.
However, it’s worth noting that it might not be the most portable option on our list, as some parents reported issues with tightening the harness straps and fastening and unfastening the LATCH, although most issues are restricted to some fabric loosening on the bottom of the seat, which is a minor concern.
As with other picks, before buying this seat, you should make sure that your child falls well within the recommended height range. Some parents felt the upper limit was restrictive compared to others, so their children outgrew the seat before making much use of it. To avoid disappointment, we’d suggest purchasing for a child who is at the lower end of the scale, unless you’re planning a lot of travel in a short space of time, as the seat is best used in high-back mode before switching to booster to maximize how long your investment lasts.
Features
- High-back mode: Supports 20-50 lbs.
- Backless mode: Supports 40-110 lbs.
- Dual cup holders
- LATCH System
- 5-Point Harness
- Up-Front Harness Adjust
- Shoulder Belt Guide
Pros
- Upfront harness adjustment.
- Dual hideaway cup holders.
- Aircraft approved.
- Supports both high-back and backless use.
Cons
- Harness straps could be difficult to tighten.
- Your child could exceed the height limit in booster mode relatively quickly.
7. Chicco KidFit 2-in-1 Belt Positioning Booster Car Seat
The Chicco KidFit booster seat comes with 10 height positions, providing ample support for your growing child. As if that wasn’t enough, it doubles as both a forward-facing high-backed car seat and a backless booster seat for maximum versatility, and its ErgoBoost double foam padding offers an unparalleled blend of support and comfort for your child.
Other desirable features include removable, foldable, and uniquely dishwasher-safe dual cup holders and a tried and trusted LATCH system that can be used to keep the seat in place even when your child isn’t riding in it. Not only does this mean you can ‘set and forget’ the seat after installation, but its kid-friendly design complete with machine-washable covers ensures you have the power to keep the seat as clean and comfortable as the day you bought it.
Being internationally manufactured, some users have noticed that the seat comes in at slightly wider than competitors designed specifically with American vehicles in mind, and some have reported that, although sturdy, the Chicco KidFit is on the heavier side.
We recommend careful checking that the seatbelt is secure and in place before use, as some parents have said that the restraints can slip.
For those with roomier vehicles, why not give this pick a try and let the reliable, comfortable design speak for itself?
Features
- High-back mode: Supports 30-100 lbs.
- Backless mode: Supports 40-110 lbs.
- Dual cup holders
- LATCH System
- 10 height positions
- SuperCinch LATCH attachment
- Dual cup holders
- 2 levels of recline
Pros
- Multiple upfront harness adjustment options.
- Seat pad and armrest covers are removable and machine washable.
- Supports both high-back and backless use.
- Offers removable, dishwasher-safe cup holders.
Cons
- Could prove difficult to fit in small cars.
Wrapping Up
Safety is the first thing on the mind of most people when picking a car seat for their 4-year-old, but as we’ve seen, there are a number of other factors you should consider to make the best possible choice for you and your child, including the different modes offered, and where your child falls in terms of weight and height limits the manufacturer specifies to get the most possible use for your money.
Our list of the safest car seats for 4-year-olds and our buyer’s guide should work together to help you choose a durable, comfortable, and safe car seat for your little one that will last many a car trip. Happy shopping!
Related Stuff
Image Credit: Mum’s Grapevine